China: The Home to Facebook and Twitter?

Being the only on-going global research on internet usage, sometimes our results are new and unfamiliar to people.

This is always the case with our data on China, particularly when researching usage of Facebook and Twitter. The official story is that nobody uses them; even Facebook’s IPO document declared that the company had no users in China. Considering China is by all measures the most active social media market on the planet and not isolated from the rest of the world, this is somewhat of a surprise.

Since Wave 1 (July 2009), we have tracked user growth for Twitter in China from 11.8m (use or contribute last month) to 35m in Q2 2012. Facebook has grown even more impressively from 7.9m to 63.52m over the same period, although we should bear in mind that due to the size of the market this only represents 8% and 15% respectively of the internet population. The sheer size of the market can turn moderate interest and adoption into a major play.

In reality, this should not be a surprise; we should, firstly, consider our methodology, which is self-completion surveys in Mandarin (Simplified Chinese for Mainland China) served to an online panel run by an internationally accredited panel company. Furthermore, we have run seven waves of research in China, covering a representative sample of the internet users from within this panel; our samples are defined by age, gender, education level to be as representative of that population as possible. For questions regarding social media usage, respondents are posed the simple question “On which of the following services have you created an account?” and are provided a list of global services and also local players . For all the selections they choose, they are then asked “On which of the following services have you used or contributed last month?” Following on from this, they then define which actions they have done on that service by PC, mobile or tablet device. It is simple, clear, and we have verified it in all markets against other forms of data.

Crucially, our methodology produces exactly the right figures for the local services that dominate (see graph below) the Chinese internet market, with 66% of Chinese internet users being active on Qzone (286m users), 61% on Sina Weibo (264m users) and 56% on Tencent Weibo (239m users).

Chinese Internet Usage

To put the domination of local services into perspective, we should examine how low the level of engagement that Twitter and Facebook exhibit in comparison to local services in China mentioned above. For example, only 34% of active Chinese Twitter users have posted a Tweet in our latest survey while 54% of UK users did so. Clearly, they are supplementary and not core social platforms.

Another interesting point is the user base structure. Taking Facebook as an example, 65% of active users are male, 69% have a post-graduate degree and 76% are under the age of 34. It’s clear that younger, internationally engaged demographic groups are driving the adoption of foreign social media services.

How are Chinese users getting onto Facebook and Twitter?

We routinely come across the argument that these sites are blocked in China, and therefore, our figures cannot possibly be correct. However, it only takes a little bit of desk research to discover that what is called the “Great Firewall” is actually much more porous than the Chinese government would like to admit. On closer inspection, Chinese users are using VPNs (Virtual Private Networks), VCN (Virtual Cloud Networks) or connections at work that may be routed internationally. Crucially, this means that users won’t be picked up in analytics and will not register as being in a Chinese location at all!

Also Chinese users are the most active mobile internet users on the planet with 78% of internet users also accessing by mobile in the last month. This compares to the UK at 55%, Japan 49% and the US at 38%. Mobile connections and apps have also made it easier to access both Facebook and Twitter. Our Asian market experts routinely see examples of this such as the recent discovery that if someone downloads the Flipboard app they can access Twitter, as this story outlines.

In addition, there are well-known active Twitter users, such as famous Chinese artist Ai Weiwei who has 120K followers and has featured in some protests (this example driving Chinese residents over to Hong Kong).

There are broader drivers that are worth considering as well. Every school child in China is learning English, and many millions now go to study abroad. In addition, hundreds of millions of Chinese have connections to family members living aboard. In other markets, these factors have been important in driving uptake of Facebook, and they will have a similar impact in China.

In short, the “Great Firewall” is not as solid as many people think and analytics and tracking data (which only track conventional connections or places Chinese users in the location of the VPN) do not tell the full story. If we actually go into the market and simply ask the people, a much more complex picture emerges, and it is this behaviour that is illuminated by the GlobalWebIndex.

17 comments on this post

  1. Guest on

    63 millions China FB users = USELESS. FB makes money from advertisers not from users. China advertisers are not able to advertise on FB = NO revenue = NO Earning = Useless. I do not think that China Advertisers want to take the risk of advertising on Facebook even if they can use proxies/VPN to access. Why? There are so many more efficient Chinese websites to advertise, why choose FB which is blocked by the government? And they certainly put their company on fire by going against the rules by Chinese government.

  2. Martin Johnson on

    We have some questions regarding this data:

    1. How many registered users are there from China for Twitter, Facebook and Google+? Your own data and tweets suggest 75 million for Twitter (via your tweet), 125 million for Facebook (also via your tweet although your report suggests 450 million) and 150 million for Google + (via the same report).

    2. How many of those users are active? Your data again suggests 35.4 million (via your blog post) but eMarketer suggests 35.5 million (via their infographic). Facebook at 63 million and Google + at 106 million (both via your infographic). How do the active user percentages for Twitter (47%), Facebook (50%) and Google + (71%) compare to other markets?

    3. Does China include Hong Kong, Macau and/or Taiwan in your reports?

    4. If Twitter has more active users in China than in the US, how come the most popular account based in China has only 562,250 followers (and is run by a foreigner)? This compares to the most followed US-based Twitter account (ladagaga: 29m followers) as well as the most followed Sina Weibo account (姚晨: 24m followers), both more than 100 times more popular.

    5. If Facebook has tens of millions of users in China, why do they themselves only claim to have 600k?

    6. If LinkedIn.com has 16m users in China and Facebook has four times as many, why does Alexa rank LinkedIn as #267 and Facebook only as #482?

    7. What is a “Virtual Cloud Network” and how do you use it to circumvent censorship? Did you ask users how they get around the Great Firewall? In our experience, free circumvention tools such as Ultrasurf and Freegate are more widespread than commercial VPNs but we lack data and it would be very interesting to know more.

    8. How did you find users to reply to your surveys in China? Was the survey in Chinese? If so, how were the names of Facebook, Twitter, Google+ and LinkedIn translated? On what websites was it advertised? Was the survey website itself blocked or throttled in China?

    https://en.greatfire.org/blog/2012/sep/8-questions-globalwebindex

  3. Guest on

    Your number is invalid. I wonder how you get this number.

    Do the following steps to get the REAL China Facebook users:-
    1. Login your Facebook Account
    2. Go to facebook.com/advertising
    3. A few clicks to create Ads
    4. Under “Location”, Key in “China” as the only country.

    I am sure you only get 600k+ users there. This is an OFFICIAL number by Facebook, it can’t be wrong.

  4. Pingback: État des lieux de Facebook avec 1 milliard d’utilisateurs « MAMESO

  5. Pingback: Belgaum news | About Belgaum | Belgaum information | Belgaum district | Belgaum city | Belgaum Hotels | Belgaum People | Belgaum tourism | Belgaum entertainment | Belgaum students | Inside facebook | Hack | make use of | technical news | | Facebook roundu

  6. Pingback: 중국 이용자가 사용하는 SNS는 뭘까? @ socialro

  7. chris robinson on

    “Last month” is hardly a suitable measure for social media research. The whole premise of social media is frequent interactions. How can such a blunt measure indicate anything? The reason why past month is used is because it is flattering to social media. Try using past 24 hours or past 3 days and see what a difference you get!

  8. Peter Olsthoorn on

    Can you please make the disstiction between visitors of the site and users with a Twitter or Facebook account? This is not clear. If millions of Chinese people have Fb profiles this means the Chinese government allows it ‘secretly’. Or not?

  9. Pingback: Gr Tec » Bloqueado na China, Facebook ainda tem 63 milhões de usuários no país

  10. air conditioning systems on

    You could certainly see your enthusiasm in the paintings you write. The world hopes for more passionate writers like you who aren’t afraid to mention how they believe. All the time go after your heart.

  11. professional survey tool on

    Its good to be aware that only only people from my country are addicted to facebook and twitter. it show that freedom of self-expression rules despite restrictions.

  12. travel on

    I like the valuable information you supply on your articles. I will bookmark your weblog and take a look at once more right here frequently. I am fairly sure I’ll learn many new stuff proper here! Good luck for the next!

  13. Pingback: 10 years on: How India is driving Asia’s love affair with Facebook | Asian Correspondent

  14. Pingback: 10 years on: How India is driving Asia’s love affair with Facebook | Robert Baird

  15. Pingback: 10 years on: How India is driving Asia’s love affair with Facebook | Newspaperhunt

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *